Three Indianapolis Top Star Enter Transfer Portal… See More…
2. Rigo Sanchez: Had a big rookie year replacing McAfee in 2017. Switched to No. 8 in Year 3.
3. Rohn Stark: Made four Pro Bowls in 11 years in Indianapolis, leading the NFL in net punting in 1985 and ’86. Chester Rogers has a long way to go to overtake Stark.
4. Jim Harbaugh: Kickers Dean Biasucci and Adam Vinatieri can stake a claim to one of the most talented numbers in Indianapolis Colts history, but Captain Comeback made Indianapolis a Colts town in 1995.
5. Kerry Collins: His primary contribution to the Colts was going 0-3 as the starting quarterback during the “Suck for Luck” campaign, but he had a long, productive NFL career. Josh Freeman and Quan Bray are Collins’ competition at this spot.
6. Dan Orlovsky: Led the 2011 Colts to their two victories, but didn’t cost the franchise the No. 1 overall pick in Andrew Luck.
7. Jacoby Brissett: He’s become a lightning rod for fans but his two years as a starter trump Gary Hogeboom’s 12 starts over three seasons.
8. Matt Hasselbeck: Tied for second on the winning percentage list (5-3, .625), and kept the Colts afloat without Luck last year at the age of 40 despite battling food poisoning and opposing defenses.
9. Mark Herrmann: The Carmel and Purdue grad spent parts of four seasons in Indianapolis as a backup quarterback.
10. Jack Trudeau: Had a 64.4 quarterback rating as the team’s off-and-on starter for eight years. Donte Moncrief is catching up quickly.
11. Jeff George: Never lived up to the expectations in his hometown, but the Colts dealt him to Atlanta for the draft pick that became Marvin Harrison.
The other choice is Anthony Gonzalez, a first-round pick who played in 40 games and made 99 catches.
12. Andrew Luck: Quickly edged Mike Vanderjagt (1998-2000) out of this spot.
